What we risk by giving shallow advice

Image Credit: Christian family worship God by doidam10, via Getty Images (accessed through Canva).

    Misapplied Scripture can lead to further hurt. It may sound odd to say that, but some of the most life-changing truths in Scripture are often misused, especially when given without much thought or prayer, or even pastoral advice.

    One, for example, is Matthew 10:37–39. I have heard it used more times than I can count. “Anyone who loves father or mother more than Me is not worthy of Me.” It is used far too quickly in response to conflict. I have seen Christians encouraged to leave their families behind at the first sign of opposition. What many forget, however, is that this passage was not given so that we can justify resentment or pride. It was spoken in the context of true discipleship, where Christ is supreme, and love remains steadfast, even to those who oppose us. 

    I say that because before someone chooses to walk away, we must ask the right questions. What have we done first? 

    Have we shared the Gospel with them, not just once, but patiently, with all our might and prayerfully? Are they even Christians, or are they walking blindly and need our light? How long have we waited? How long have we prayed? Some believers have endured for years, pleading in tears for their parents, siblings, or children. Some of us may have stayed silent and stood only when insulted, not realizing that our silence or pride may have deepened the gap. When they opposed our faith, did we explain it gently, or did we snap back? Did we show them the Christ who died for them, even while they were hostile?

    Every believer must come to a place of self-conviction. I cannot say we must stay or that we must leave. But I can say this: we should not rush to either. We should not despise the sacrifice if we have chosen to stay, and not despise the sorrow of walking away if we had no other choice. Many believers say, “You should have just left them,” while others say, “You should have endured longer.” But only the one carrying the burden knows how heavy it truly is. Let each person weigh the matter before God, with accountability and genuine self-reflection.

    If we feel the time has come to focus on outside ministry, let us ask ourselves again: Did I truly do my part as a Christian inside the home? Have I sacrificed in love, or did I just get tired of trying? Of course, obedience to Christ is not measured by effort alone. There are clear biblical commands that require immediate action. If the Lord calls someone to take a step of separation, that step must be taken in trust. But even when we need to quickly obey, it must never be thoughtless. Let the decision come from prayer. There are indeed situations, such as abuse or relentless hostility, where immediate separation may be necessary as a way to preserve life and faithfulness to God. In such cases, enduring longer may not be what God requires.

    But sometimes the problem is not the verse. Sometimes, it is the heart that wields it. If we are not watchful, we can use Scripture like a sword against the very people Christ calls us to love. The same applies to verses such as “Do not be unequally yoked” or “Shake the dust off your feet.” Because they are not meant to be uttered in passing. They call for discernment, and above all, a heart that truly loves others and trembles at the Word of God. Scripture must remain central to our every conversation. But centrality does not mean simplicity. We must speak it in season and with reverence, ensuring that it is rightly divided and humbly applied (2 Tim 2:15). This does not mean we should hesitate to speak God’s Word. Scripture remains the final authority. But it must be spoken in a way that reflects both its power and its purpose, to correct and restore (2 Tim 3:16–17).

    There are also instances when it is not just a verse that is misused, but an entire approach to suffering. A believer might say they are depressed, and someone quickly tells them to not put on their hands what only God can handle or to “Just have more faith,” or to “not worry about things beyond your control.” Sometimes, verses such as “Cast all your anxiety on Him because He cares for you” (1 Pet 5:7) or “Do not be anxious about anything” (Phil 4:6) are just thrown hastily and lazily, as if quoting them alone should resolve the gravity someone bears. Those may indeed be intended for one's wellness, but they often disregard the fact that the person might already know that. They are simply processing the burden, not rejecting God's truth. They may still be walking with God, just limping for a time. And perhaps they are not asking for a theological answer but simply for someone to listen without outright judgment. When we speak before listening (Prov. 18:13), we miss the full picture of what they are bearing. Even when Scripture is true, it must be timed and tempered.

    So, if we give advice, let us not merely hand out verses. Let us not be content with just being right. If our counsel lacks prayer and sincere compassion, we may speak what is correct in principle yet cause a brother to stumble in practice. And if we are the ones seeking counsel, let us not rest on one verse. Speak with elders or pastors. Or with someone whose walk has been tested and proven in faith. That is one reason they are placed in our lives. At the same time, each believer must take ownership of their own walk with God. Even when advice is sincere and sounds biblical, it must be tested against the truth of Scripture. The Spirit gives wisdom to those who ask (Jas 1:5).

    Most of all, do not cease to seek wisdom from the throne of grace. There is no danger in doing so. The Bible is the very breath of God. The ability to apply it rightly comes only from Him. Let us then handle His word with reverence. Let us not be swift to speak when God calls us to wait, or even to weep. And a wise counselor will not end with quoting a verse but will remain with a brother, helping him to walk through its meaning with patience and love.

“Now we exhort you, brethren, warn those who are unruly, comfort the fainthearted, uphold the weak, be patient with all.”(1 Thess. 5:14)